Featured Article – 2009 August
Monitoring the Distressed Auto Dealer
by Christopher Beane CMC
These are troubling times for auto dealers, no matter whether the make they sell is domestic or imported. Chrysler has announced that it is dropping 789 dealerships, cutting its network by 25 percent. By October of next year, General Motors will sever relationships with 1,100 of its dealerships, and it is requiring the dealers that remain in its network to sign new “participation agreements” that will set more stringent sales and inventory requirements.
Overall, new vehicles sales and leases are down sharply, from 17.1 million in 2007 to an estimate of between 9 million and 10 million this year. Sales and lease totals haven’t been so low since 1991, when 12.3 million new vehicles were sold or leased. In this economy, only the most exceptional dealers are doing as well as they were two or three years ago.
Out of trust
Given the severe market pressures some dealers are facing, cash flow becomes a serious issue. Desperation may lead some dealers to use floor plan loan proceeds as a source of cash to fund operating losses – the classic out of trust scenario. Given the severe pressures dealers are facing, it’s easy to understand why sales and inventory totals might not be reported accurately.
Typically, we are asked to get involved when lenders suspect the dealer is
- out of trust with respect to the floor plan;
- not providing accurate reporting;
- violating financial covenants;
- delaying its financial reports.
Our work inside the dealership provides lenders with critical information that helps in their decision-making.
When we take on an assignment, we place a consultant on site at the dealership for anywhere from one to five days a week or for as long as is needed for the lender to regain confidence in the reports provided by the dealership and to ensure that the issues have been resolved.
By being on site we build a rapport with the staff and gain valuable insights into the organization’s overall operations. Because of our broad experience with troubled businesses in numerous industries, we have the background to assess management style and experience, how relationships within the ownership group affect overall operation, procedural and operational deficiencies within the accounting department, and the quality of interaction among the finance, sales and accounting departments.
By entrenching ourselves within the dealership, Beane Associates becomes a valuable source of reliable information.
Developing daily flash reports detailing sales and projected payments to the vehicle floor plan and other critical information in a concise and easy to understand format builds trust and accountability.
Additionally while on-site we also take responsibility for:
- Retention and distribution of vehicle titles to ensure that the title is not released until the vehicle is paid for;
- Ensuring payroll and sales taxes are current;
- Monitoring loan covenants and forbearance stipulations;
- Coordinating and analyzing the work product generated by third-party car counting firms.
It’s a matter of trust
Floor plan lending can be a very profitable and rewarding business for lenders. However, in times of distress the relatively large amounts of cash transactions involved in this type of lending can present unique challenges. At the end of the day, our experience has shown that quick and visible response to any potential out of trust situation is the best approach to ensuring that every car that is supposed to be sold, on the lot or in the showroom is accounted for.
For more information or comments please contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org